Are Bread Makers Worth It? Drawbacks of a Bread Maker

Bread makers are ideal for people who enjoy freshly baked bread but lack the time or expertise to bake it from scratch. They are also suitable for individuals with dietary restrictions or allergies, as they can control all ingredients. Furthermore, those who appreciate the process of baking and enjoy the comforting aroma of bread baking at home may find a bread maker a worthwhile investment.

Bread Maker

Why should you buy a Bread Maker?


A bread maker does all the hard work for you. You just have to add ingredients and select the setting. It kneads, proves, and bakes, simplifying the process, especially for beginners or people with busy schedules.

Control over ingredients

You have full control over what goes into your bread, allowing you to use healthier options, avoid certain allergens, or cater to specific dietary requirements. This is not always possible with store-bought bread.

Control over ingredients


There’s nothing quite like the taste and smell of freshly baked bread. With a bread maker, you can have this experience whenever you want, without going to a bakery or supermarket.


While the initial cost of a bread maker can be relatively high, it can pay for itself over time. Homemade bread is generally cheaper than store-bought, especially for artisan or specialty breads.


Most bread makers have a variety of settings that allow you to make different types of bread, including white, whole grain, gluten-free, and more. Some models even have settings for things like jams or yogurts.

Consistent results

A bread maker produces consistent results every time, taking away the guesswork involved in traditional baking. Once you find a recipe you love, you can recreate it perfectly every time.

Consistent results


A bread maker has a timer function lets you delay the baking process. You can load it up in the evening and wake up to fresh, warm bread in the morning.

Minimal cleanup

Baking bread traditionally can be messy and requires cleaning multiple utensils and bowls. With a bread maker, everything is done within the machine, which minimizes cleanup.

Energy efficient

Baking in a traditional oven can use considerable energy, especially for a single loaf of bread. A bread maker uses less energy, which can be more environmentally friendly and cost-effective.

Energy efficient


Besides bread, many bread makers can make other items, such as dough for pizzas or pastries, cakes, and even jams. This versatility can make it a valuable addition to your kitchen.

Drawbacks of a Bread Maker

Initial Cost

Bread makers can be quite expensive initially, especially high-end models. This might not be a feasible investment for those on a tight budget.

Space Requirement

Bread makers are generally bulky appliances that can take up significant counter space in your kitchen. This can be an issue for those with smaller kitchens or limited storage space.

Space Requirement

Limited Loaf Size

Most bread makers bake only one size of the loaf, and it may not suit everyone’s needs. For large families or for those who consume bread frequently, a single loaf might not be enough.

Learning Curve

Even though bread makers simplify the bread-making process, there can still be a learning curve involved, especially when figuring out the right quantities and types of ingredients for different recipes.


Bread makers can be noisy during the kneading process. This might not be ideal for those who prefer a quieter environment, especially if you use the timer function to make bread overnight.


Bread Shape

The bread produced by a bread maker usually has an unusual shape (a tall or square loaf) and a hole in the bottom where the mixing paddle is. Some people might find this aesthetically unpleasing compared to traditionally baked bread.

Who should buy a Bread Maker Machine?

Busy Home Bakers: Those who love home-baked bread but are pressed for time would benefit from a bread maker. It handles the mixing, kneading, rising, and baking, reducing active involvement and making the process more convenient.

Health-Conscious Individuals: A bread maker is great for people who want to control what goes into their bread. You can choose high-quality, nutritious ingredients and eliminate preservatives and unnecessary additives.

People with Dietary Restrictions: Those with dietary restrictions or allergies can greatly benefit from a bread maker. It allows for preparing specialty breads, such as gluten-free or low-sodium, at a much lower cost than store-bought alternatives.

Frequent Bread Eaters: A bread maker can be cost-effective in the long run for households that consume bread frequently. The cost of ingredients is often lower than buying fresh loaves regularly from a store or bakery.

Who should buy a Bread Maker Machine

Who should not buy a Bread Maker Machine?

Infrequent Bread Eaters: Those who don’t eat bread regularly might not get enough use from a bread maker to justify the cost and counter space it takes up.

Traditional Baking Enthusiasts: People who love the traditional bread-making process might not enjoy being a bread maker. The manual kneading and proofing process can be therapeutic and rewarding for some.

Space-Conscious Individuals: If you have a small kitchen with limited counter or storage space, a bread maker might not be ideal. They are typically bulky and can take up a significant amount of room.

Budget-Constrained Buyers: While bread makers can be cost-effective over time, the initial investment can be significant. Those on a tight budget might find this initial cost prohibitive.

Who should not buy a Bread Maker Machine

Bread Maker vs. Hand Bread Making


Bread Maker: A bread maker automates the kneading process, ensuring the dough is thoroughly worked without any effort on your part. This is particularly helpful for those with difficulty kneading manually due to arthritis or other issues.

Hand Bread Making: Manual kneading requires physical effort and technique. However, it provides a tactile experience that many bakers enjoy and allows for adjustments based on the feel of the dough.


Bread Maker: Bread makers produce bread in a specific shape based on the design of the machine, typically a cube or a tall rectangle. Custom shaping isn’t possible.

Hand Bread Making: With manual bread making, you have complete control over the shape of your bread. You can create traditional loaves, baguettes, rolls, braids, and other shapes.


Bread Maker: Bread makers come with built-in timers and programs. You can set it up and forget it until the bread is done and even program it to have fresh bread ready when you wake up.

Hand Bread Making: Manual bread making requires more active involvement and monitoring. You need to knead, allow for rising time, shape, and then bake, all of which must be timed correctly for a successful loaf.


Bread Maker: Most bread makers can only bake one loaf at a time. The size of the loaf is also fixed based on the machine’s capacity.

Hand Bread Making: With manual baking, you can make as many loaves as your oven can accommodate. This allows you to make larger quantities of bread, which is particularly useful for large families or gatherings.


Bread Maker: Many bread makers have settings that let you control the crust’s darkness. However, it may not achieve the same variety of textures as a traditional oven.

Hand Bread Making: In a conventional oven, you have more control over the baking environment, which can result in a greater variety of crust types. You can create everything from a soft, light crust to a dark, thick crust.

Bread Maker vs. Hand Bread Making

Frequently Asked Questions

Which is cheaper: buying bread or making it in a bread machine?

In the long run, making bread in a bread machine is typically cheaper. While there is an initial investment for the machine, the cost of ingredients per loaf is often less than buying commercially prepared bread, especially for specialty types.

Which is better: making bread by hand or by machine?

This depends on personal preferences. A machine offers convenience and consistency, while handmade bread provides a tactile, rewarding experience and more control over the process.

What is the average running cost of a bread maker?

Beyond the initial cost of the machine, the main running cost is the electricity it uses, which is typically minimal, and the cost of ingredients. Depending on the recipe, this can average between $0.50 to $2.00 per loaf.

Can I use a bread maker for dough kneading?

Yes, most bread makers have a dough setting that mixes and kneads the dough without baking, which is useful for making pizza dough, pretzels, or other non-loaf baked goods.

Can I use a bread maker for making jam, yogurt, and cakes?

Many modern bread makers come with settings for making jams and cakes. The yogurt function is less common but available in some models. Always refer to your machine’s manual for specific capabilities.

Can I make sourdough bread in a bread maker?

Yes, you can make sourdough bread in a bread maker. However, you’ll still need to maintain a sourdough starter separately, as this process requires a fermentation period outside the machine. The bread maker can then be used for the kneading and baking process.


I live in Los Angeles with my better half, Dave, and our child, Corey. Each second with them is the acknowledgment of my fantasies working out as expected — and for that? I am so extremely thankful. Hi! I am Diana Rodriguez, the founder, author, and photographer of ATD.

Leave a Comment