Immersion Blender vs. Hand Mixer: Which Is More Useful?

Immersion Blender

An immersion blender, or a stick or hand blender, is a kitchen tool used to blend ingredients directly in the container where they are being prepared. This handheld device is compact and versatile, allowing for easy blending of hot and cold ingredients.

Immersion Blender

Uses of an Immersion Blender

Pureeing Soup: Immersion blenders can easily puree soup right in the pot, eliminating the need to transfer hot liquids to a countertop blender. This method provides a smooth, uniform soup texture.

Making Smoothies: You can use an immersion blender to mix fruits, yogurt, and other ingredients directly in a glass or jug to make smoothies, offering quick cleanup and convenience.

Whipping Cream: Immersion blenders can also be used to whip cream. They create a fluffy, light texture perfect for topping desserts or hot drinks.

Blending Baby Food: Immersion blenders are ideal for blending fruits, vegetables, and meats into a puree, creating easy-to-digest meals for infants.

Making Mayonnaise: You can make homemade mayonnaise by slowly adding oil to egg yolks while blending with an immersion blender. This method ensures the emulsion forms properly.

Creating Sauces and Dressings: Immersion blenders can blend various ingredients to create smooth sauces or dressings, providing consistent flavors and textures.

Blending Pancake or Waffle Batter: Immersion blenders can make a smooth, lump-free batter for pancakes or waffles directly in the mixing bowl, simplifying the preparation process.

Chopping Small Amounts of Food: Some immersion blenders come with a chopper attachment, which is handy for chopping small amounts of foods like nuts, herbs, or onions. This feature eliminates the need for a full-sized food processor for small tasks.

Hand Mixer

A hand mixer is a small, handheld kitchen device used to mix, beat, or whip ingredients. It typically comes with detachable beaters and is ideal for lightweight tasks requiring quick, convenient blending or mixing.

Hand Mixer

Use of a Hand Mixer

Beating Eggs: A hand mixer can aerate eggs quickly, creating a fluffy consistency for scrambled eggs or omelets. It’s also ideal for beating egg whites to stiff peaks for meringues or other pastries.

Whipping Cream: Hand mixers can whip cream to the desired consistency. It can create a light, fluffy texture perfect for cakes, pies, or beverages.

Mixing Cake Batter: When making cakes or muffins, a hand mixer ensures a smooth, well-mixed batter, helping to evenly distribute the ingredients for a consistent result.

Creaming Butter and Sugar: A common step in baking, hand mixers effectively cream together butter and sugar, which provides a light and fluffy base for cookies, cakes, and other desserts.

Making Frosting: Hand mixers are perfect for making frostings or icings, thoroughly blending butter, sugar, and flavorings to achieve a creamy, smooth consistency.

Making Dips: A hand mixer can help achieve a smooth, well-blended texture for creamy dips like hummus or guacamole. It’s also good for blending soft cheeses for dips or spreads.

Kneading Dough: Some hand mixers come with dough hook attachments, allowing for easier bread dough kneading, though they are typically less powerful than stand mixers.

Preparing Mashed Potatoes: Hand mixers can be used to mash boiled potatoes, adding in butter, milk, or cream as needed to achieve a creamy, smooth consistency without lumps.

Can you interchange an Immersion Blender with a Hand Mixer?

Things You Can Do When Replacing These Tools

A hand mixer can replace an immersion blender for tasks like whipping cream, beating eggs, and mixing batter.

An immersion blender can replace a hand mixer for tasks such as blending soups, making smoothies, and blending hot ingredients directly in a pot.

Things You Can’t Do When Replacing These Tools

A hand mixer can’t replace an immersion blender for blending hot liquids directly in a pot, as it’s unsafe.

An immersion blender cannot incorporate as much air as a hand mixer, which might not produce fluffy or light textures when whipping cream or beating eggs.

An immersion blender won’t work well for tasks that require incorporating dry and wet ingredients in stages, like making cookie or cake dough, which a hand mixer can handle effectively.

A hand mixer isn’t suitable for tasks that require blending in a narrow container, such as making smoothies directly in a glass, a task for which an immersion blender is designed.

Can you interchange an Immersion Blender with a Hand Mixer

Immersion Blender vs. Hand Mixer: Similarities & Differences


Handheld Devices: Both handheld kitchen appliances provide convenience and portability, allowing users to move around the kitchen easily.

Mixing Ability: Both appliances are designed to mix ingredients. They can blend, mix, puree, and whip various foods to different consistencies.

Ease of Cleaning: Hand mixers and immersion blenders usually come with detachable parts, making them easy to clean after use.

Versatility: Both appliances are versatile, handling various ingredients and food preparation tasks.

Speed Settings: Both tools typically offer multiple speed settings, allowing you to adjust the power based on the task.


Design: An immersion blender has a stick-like design with blades at the end, while a hand mixer has two rotating beaters.

Functionality: Immersion blenders can blend ingredients directly in any container, even hot ones. Hand mixers, however, are more suited for mixing ingredients in a bowl.

Aeration: Hand mixers are more effective at incorporating air into mixtures (like whipped cream or beaten eggs), producing lighter, fluffier results. Immersion blenders, while able to whip, don’t incorporate as much air.

Handling Liquids: Immersion blenders are better at handling liquids and can even blend hot soup in the pot. Hand mixers aren’t suitable for blending liquids unless they are in a deep bowl to prevent splattering.

Attachments: Hand mixers often come with beaters, dough hooks, and sometimes whisk attachments. Immersion blenders usually have a blade for blending and may come with a whisk or chopper attachment.

Immersion Blender vs. Hand Mixer Similarities & Differences

Immersion Blender vs. Hand Mixer: Do You Need Both?

Whether you need an immersion blender or a hand mixer depends on your specific cooking and baking needs. If you frequently make soups, sauces, and smoothies, an immersion blender’s ability to blend directly in the pot or glass is invaluable.

On the other hand, if you do a lot of baking that involves whipping cream, beating eggs, or mixing dough, a hand mixer would be more suitable. If your kitchen tasks regularly involve both these types of food preparations, having both appliances would be beneficial.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I mix a cake with an immersion blender?

Yes, you can mix a cake batter with an immersion blender, especially if it’s a liquid batter. However, it may not incorporate as much air as a hand mixer, potentially affecting the cake’s final texture.

Can you make mashed potatoes with an immersion blender?

Yes, you can make mashed potatoes with an immersion blender. It can mash the boiled potatoes to a smooth consistency, though care must be taken not to over-process, as this can result in a gluey texture.

Can you cream butter and sugar with an immersion blender?

Creaming butter and sugar with an immersion blender can be difficult because the process requires aeration, which an immersion blender might not achieve as effectively as a hand mixer. Still, it’s possible if you use a high-speed setting.

Can you blend ice with an immersion blender?

Most immersion blenders are not designed to crush ice. Doing so could damage the blades or the motor. Refer to your specific model’s user manual to determine what it can handle.

What can I use instead of a hand mixer?

A stand mixer is an excellent alternative if a hand mixer is not available. If neither is available, a whisk or a fork can also be used for mixing, though these require more effort and time.

How can I blend without a hand mixer?

If you don’t have a hand mixer, you can use a whisk or a fork to blend ingredients manually. It requires more effort, but it’s doable. An immersion blender or a countertop blender could also work for tasks like pureeing or blending.


I live in Los Angeles with my better half, Dave, and our child, Corey. Each second with them is the acknowledgment of my fantasies working out as expected — and for that? I am so extremely thankful. Hi! I am Diana Rodriguez, the founder, author, and photographer of ATD.

Leave a Comment